Common Interview Mistakes Made by Employers


• September 29, 2023

Here, we are focusing on the common mistakes employers make during interviews.


Let’s delve into a specific aspect, providing insights and practical advice for improving the hiring process.


#1: Unstructured Interviews


Unstructured interviews can lead to inconsistency in the hiring process. When there is no standardised framework or set of predetermined questions, different interviewers may focus on different things or ask different questions, making it hard to compare candidates objectively. This can result in biased decisions and the possibility of overlooking qualified candidates.


Moreover, these interviews may not provide a complete understanding of how well a candidate fits into the organisation. Without consistent questions and evaluation criteria, it's challenging to assess cultural fit, teamwork skills, and alignment with company values. This may result in unintentionally hiring candidates who don't align with the company culture.


To address these issues, employers should implement structured interviews that include a standardised set of questions, relevant competencies, and evaluation criteria. This approach promotes fairness, consistency, and a more accurate assessment of candidates, resulting in better hiring decisions and positive candidate experiences.


#2. Exaggerating the Role


Firstly, exaggerating the role sets false expectations for the candidate regarding the responsibilities, challenges, and opportunities associated with the position. When the actual job doesn't align with what was promised during the interview, it can lead to employee dissatisfaction and frustration. This may result in decreased motivation, reduced productivity, and even increased turnover as employees feel misled.


Additionally, exaggerating the role can have adverse effects on team dynamics and performance. When a new hire joins with inflated expectations, their colleagues and managers may struggle to manage those expectations, resulting in strained working relationships. The mismatch between the promised role and the actual responsibilities can lead to confusion, conflicts, and an inefficient allocation of resources. Ultimately, this can hinder collaboration, productivity, and the achievement of team objectives.


To avoid the consequences of exaggerating the role, employers should provide an accurate and transparent representation of the position during the hiring process. This includes clearly outlining the responsibilities, expectations, and potential challenges involved. By setting realistic expectations, employers can attract candidates who are genuinely interested in the role and possess the necessary skills and motivations. Honesty and transparency throughout the recruitment process contribute to positive employee experiences, higher job satisfaction, and a stronger employer brand.


#3. Dominating the Interview Dialogue


First and foremost, dominating the interview dialogue hampers the ability to gain a comprehensive understanding of the candidate's skills, experiences, and suitability for the role. By doing this, employers limit the opportunity for candidates to showcase their capabilities and express themselves fully. It can result in a superficial evaluation that does not provide a holistic picture of the candidate's qualifications.


Furthermore, dominating the dialogue can create an intimidating or one-sided atmosphere, making candidates feel unheard or undervalued. This can hinder their ability to relax and perform at their best during the interview. It also fails to foster a positive candidate experience, potentially leading to a negative perception of the company and its interview process.


To avoid dominating the interview dialogue, employers should practice active listening and create a balanced dialogue during interviews. This involves giving candidates ample time to respond to questions, asking follow-up questions to delve deeper into their experiences, and creating a supportive environment that encourages open communication. By actively engaging with candidates and valuing their perspectives, employers can gain a more comprehensive understanding of their qualifications and foster a positive candidate experience that reflects well on the organisation

Stay ahead of the talent market

Discover market intelligence, hiring trends and practical advice to help you build stronger teams.

Contact Us

SHARE THIS


Recent jobs

More insights

Two people seated indoors against a brown wall with a large leafy plant behind them.
October 14, 2026
Your first career step shouldn’t be taken alone. Hear Jade Blackburn and Jani Peut on Perigon Group’s Buddy and Mentor Program. Graduate Program 2027 is open.
Two women seated in armchairs, smiling in a warmly lit indoor lounge with plants and wall sconces.
September 24, 2026
What does it look like to build a career in recruitment at Perigon Group? It starts with the right foundations. Our Rookie Program gives new consultants hands-on training, guidance and support as they take their first steps in recruitment. As they grow, our Talent Development Program provides the next stage of development, helping our people continue building their skills and confidence. And who better to talk about that journey than someone who has lived it? Our Director Sara Vanderheld started her career as a principal consultant and has progressed through the business to become a Director, supported by our Talent Development Program along the way. In this video, Sara chats with Elle Borissow , who experienced our Rookie Program firsthand, about career development, growth and what it’s like to build a career at Perigon Group. Career growth shouldn’t be left to chance. It should be supported, developed and built with you. If this is the career and experience you're looking for, register your interest today for our latest Graduate Program 2027 below!
September 2, 2026
The role of the Finance Manager is changing. Traditionally, Finance Managers have been responsible for financial reporting, budgeting, forecasting and compliance. Today, organisations increasingly expect them to do much more: influence strategy, support commercial decisions and lead finance transformation. For businesses hiring their next finance leader, the question is no longer simply whether someone can manage the numbers. Can they help the business make better decisions? 5 capabilities shaping the next generation of Finance Managers 1. Commercial thinking Finance Managers are increasingly expected to move beyond reporting what happened and help shape what happens next. That means understanding the broader business, challenging assumptions and translating financial insights into commercial recommendations. In Australia, Hays has identified commercial acumen as one of the most important capabilities for senior finance leaders, highlighting the growing importance of finance professionals who can operate as true business partners. 2. FP&A and strategic planning Forecasting and budgeting remain core responsibilities, but today's Finance Manager needs to think in scenarios. Strong FP&A capability allows finance leaders to identify risks, model opportunities and give leadership teams a clearer view of what lies ahead. 3. Technology and transformation Automation, AI, data and ERP transformation are changing how finance teams operate. Finance Managers don't need to be technologists, but they do need to understand how technology can improve processes, reporting and decision-making. According to Hays, 51% of organisations in Australia's Financial and Insurance Services sector report skills gaps, reinforcing the challenge businesses face in finding professionals with the right combination of technical and future-focused capabilities. 4. Communication and influence The modern Finance Manager needs to communicate with more than the finance team. Whether presenting to executives, partnering with operations or challenging a commercial decision, they need to turn complex financial information into clear, actionable insights. Technical expertise gets the conversation started. Communication and influence help move it forward. 5. People leadership As finance functions become more strategic and multidisciplinary, Finance Managers are also becoming increasingly important people leaders. The ability to develop talent, lead change and build high-performing teams is becoming just as important as technical capability. Hiring for what comes next The best Finance Manager for an organisation isn't necessarily the person with the longest list of technical credentials. It is the person whose capabilities match where the business is going. For a growing organisation, that might mean commerciality and FP&A. For an ASX-listed business, it could be reporting, governance and stakeholder management. For a business undergoing transformation, technology and change leadership may be critical.
Two people seated indoors against a brown wall with a large leafy plant behind them.
October 14, 2026
Your first career step shouldn’t be taken alone. Hear Jade Blackburn and Jani Peut on Perigon Group’s Buddy and Mentor Program. Graduate Program 2027 is open.